Info@liblaw.org

Document Category Commercial Law


TitleCategoriesTagsLinkhf:tax:document_titlehf:doc_tagshf:doc_categories
A.D.C. Airlines v Sannoh LRSC 11; 38 LLR 615 (1998), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , a-d-c-airlines-v-sannoh-lrsc-11-38-llr-615-1998 knuckles-v-tradevco1998-opinions accrual-of-cause-of-action appellate-review banking-law breach-of-deposit-contract civil-law commercial-law conversion correspondence costs-assessed currency-denomination damages-for-wrong deposit-account disposition-of-law-issues last-transaction-rule liberian-dollar-account mandate montserrado-county mutual-open-and-current-account notice reciprocal-demands remand retrial-ordered reversal sixth-judicial-circuit statute-of-limitations supreme-court-of-liberia time-bar united-states-dollar-account written-demand wrongful-withholding1998-1 banking-law civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases private-wrongs-law-cases supreme-court
Access Bank Liberia (Limited) v. Wael Gharzerddine (2024), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , access-bank-liberia-limited-v-wael-gharzerddine-20242024-opinions accessbank-liberia-limited action-of-damages appellate-review arcelormittal auto-elegance banking-law breach-of-contract commercial-court-of-liberia commercial-law contract-law corporate-succession costs credibility-of-witnesses cross-examination-inconsistency damages-for-wrong documentary-evidence general-damages implied-admission legal-capacity-to-sue lost-profits mandate mitigation modification-of-judgment monrovia montserrado-county non-retroactivity one-judge-jurisdiction preponderance-of-evidence proof-of-special-damages punitive-damages shareholder-rights sole-proprietorship special-damages standing statutory-threshold subject-matter-jurisdiction subpoena supreme-court-of-liberia three-judge-panel tort-law wael-gharzeddine2024-1 banking-law civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases corporate-law-case evidence-law private-wrongs-law-cases supreme-court
Acquillas Construction Company v. The Government of the Republic of Liberia (2023), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , acquillas-construction-company-v-the-government-of-the-republic-of-liberia-20232023-opinions action-of-debt allegations-of-fraud arbitration article-iii article-vii bondholder-claims certiorari chambers-justice civil-law-court civil-procedure commercial-court commercial-court-act commercial-dispute commercial-dispute-resolution commercial-law debt-action duplicated-bonds evidentiary-dispute expert-determination extortion-allegations factual-disputes-in-commercial-cases financial-instruments fraud government-of-liberia inflated-claim interlocutory-ruling jurisdictional-challenge jury-trial ministry-of-finance montserrado-county national-bank-of-liberia national-savings-bonds non-jury-trial peremptory-writ-denied petition-for-writ-of-certiorari prompt-disposition-of-commercial-cases public-debt redemption-of-bonds referees remedial-process reversal savings-bonds sixth-judicial-circuit specialized-courts statutory-interpretation subject-matter-jurisdiction supreme-court-of-liberia trial-court-error unjust-enrichment verification-process writ-quashed2023-1 arbitration civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases evidence-law supreme-court
Afriland Bank Liberia Limited v The Management of Kailondo, Inc. (2025), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , afriland-bank-liberia-limited-v-the-management-of-kailondo2025-opinions appellate-review audit-report banking-law commercial-law counsel-fees court-appointed-referee default demand-letter due-process escrow-deposit foreclosure-of-mortgage interest-and-penalties loan-restructuring montserrado-county mortgage-deed motion-to-rescind-judgment notice-requirement objection-to-referee-report overdraft-facility proper-accounting reversal-and-remand scope-of-reference secured-transactions supreme-court-of-liberia2025-1 banking-law civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases property-law-cases supreme-court
APM Terminals Ltd. v TRH Trading Corporation and Fresh Frozen Food (2025), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , apm-terminals-ltd-v-trh-trading-corporation-and-fresh-frozen-food-20252025-opinion apm-terminals-liberia commercial-court concession-agreement contractual-authority declaratory-judgment freeport-of-monrovia fresh-frozen-food health-and-safety-standards ministry-of-commerce property-rights reefer-containers regulatory-compliance supreme-court-of-liberia tariff-guide trh-trading-corporation unauthorized-plugging2025-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases property-law-cases supreme-court
Appleton v RL LRSC 31; 23 LLR 109 (1974), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , appleton-v-rl-lrsc-31-23-llr-109-19741974-opinions abuse-of-office appellate-review assistant-county-attorney bias border-control county-inspector criminal-law customs-enforcement discharge-without-day evidentiary-insufficiency failure-to-charge-an-offense fair-trial fourth-judicial-circuit improper-jury-argument indictment inflammatory-remarks judicial-neutrality justice-of-the-peace law-license-requirement malfeasance maryland-county motion-for-new-trial motion-in-arrest-of-judgment no-adverse-inference official-duties official-misconduct prosecutorial-misconduct public-officers public-policy reversal right-to-remain-silent seizure-of-goods sufficiency-of-indictment sunday-collins supreme-court-of-liberia unauthorized-practice-of-law unlawful-authorization verdict-contrary-to-the-evidence1974-1 commercial-law-cases constitutional-law-cases criminal-law-cases national-security-law supreme-court
Armstrong v Citadel Mining Services & Construction Liberia Ltd. (2025), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , armstrong-v-citadel-mining-services-construction-liberia-ltd-20252025-opinions appellate-review automatic-renewal-clause bomi-county citadel-mining-services-construction-liberia-ltd clause-three-demobilization contractual-obligation debt-by-attachment debt-court equipment-possession equipment-rental-agreement hans-armstrong lis-pendens montserrado-county motion-to-dismiss remand-for-trial res-judicata supreme-court-of-liberia western-cluster-iron-ore-mining-company2025-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases supreme-court
Blackie et al v The Intestate Estate of Patrick Wolo Saryene (2025), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , blackie-et-al-v-the-intestate-estate-of-patrick-wolo-saryene-20252025-opinions admissions affirmation-of-judgment appellate-review best-evidence-rule burden-of-proof cancellation-of-mortgage capacity-to-sue-and-be-sued chain-of-title civil-law decedent-estates-law ejectment encroachment estate-administration estoppel fraudulent-conveyance gardnersville-township intestate-estate jury-verdict land-dispute letters-of-administration montserrado-county mortgage-agreement national-housing-authority real-property renewal-of-mortgage stephen-a-tolbert-housing-estate supreme-court-of-liberia title-deed validity-of-deed void-deed writ-of-possession wrongful-withholding2025-1 commercial-law-cases evidence-law inheritance-law-cases property-law-cases supreme-court
Blamo v Zulu et al LRSC 16; 30 LLR 586 (1983), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , abandonment-of-defense action-of-debt appellate-review attachment attorneys-fees-dispute chambers-justice damages-vs-debt enforcement-of-judgment-stayed grand-gedeh-county jurisdictional-error peoples-debt-court pleadings-and-averments rule-7-circuit-court-rules subject-matter-jurisdiction supreme-court-of-liberia trial-procedure void-judgment witness-oath-requirement writ-of-prohibition1983-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases evidence-law supreme-court
Consolidated Group, Inc. v. SATCON Communication Services et al (2025), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , consolidated-group inc-v-satcon-communication-services-et-al-20252025-opinions agency-authority bein-sports broadcasting commercial-law content-rights damages dstv english-premier-league injunction intellectual-property la-liga liberia-supreme-court liberia-telecommunication-authority multichoice piracy representative-agreement standing-to-sue supersport telecommunications2025-1 commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases corporate-law-case evidence-law intellectual-property-law private-wrongs-law-cases supreme-court
Doe v. His Honor Joseph N. Nagbe et al (2021), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , doe-v-his-honor-joseph-n-nagbe-et-al-20212021-opinions action-of-debt-for-severance-benefits admission-of-indebtedness-sum-certain civil-procedure-law corporate-handbook-benefits-vs-severance debt-court-vs-ministry-of-labour decent-work-act-2015-s-14-5c employer-employee-vs-debtor-creditor-relationship extraordinary-writ-limits-prohibition-not-substitute-for-appeal jackson-f-doe-jr justice-joseph-n-nagbe-chambers justice-yussif-d-kaba labor-law lprc-liberia-petroleum-refining-company petition-for-writ-of-prohibition presidential-appointee-managing-director subject-matter-jurisdiction supreme-court-of-liberia2021-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases labor-law-cases supreme-court
Douyeya Business Center v. Milochewsky, Jr. (2025), , , , , , , , , , , , , douyeya-business-center-v-milochewsky jr-20252025-opinions action-of-debt civil-procedure commercial-dispute contract-law damages debt-court jurisdiction sales-transaction supreme-court-of-liberia2025-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases private-wrongs-law-cases supreme-court
Eco Fuel VS. Srimex Oil & Gas (2019), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , eco-fuel-vs-srimex-oil-gas-20192019-opinions abuse-of-discretion appellate-procedure chambers-justice civil-law-court concurrent-jurisdiction contractual-rights declaratory-judgment indemnity-bond lease-agreement monrovia montserrado-county petroleum-storage-facility preliminary-injunction stay-of-enforcement supreme-court-of-liberia temporary-restraining-order writ-of-mandamus2019-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases property-law-cases supreme-court
Ecobank Liberia Limited v The Management of Consolidated Group, Inc. (2020), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ecobank-liberia-limited-v-the-management-of-consolidated-group-inc-2020 ecobank-v-consolidated-group-20202020-opinions action-of-debt alternative-writ-quashed appeal banking-law banking-transaction certiorari-interlocutory-review chambers-justice-ruling-reversed civil-law civil-procedure-law-sections-5-51-and-6-1 commercial-court commercial-law consolidated-group contracts-express-or-implied corporate-guarantee costs-to-abide-final-determination debt-action debt-court default ecobank-liberia-limited exhaustion-of-remedies guaranty inc joinder-of-parties jurisdiction leasehold-mortgage loan-facility mandate-to-resume-jurisdiction medium-term-loan monrovia montserrado-county mortgage-foreclosure necessary-parties peremptory-writ-denied permissive-joinder personal-guarantee petition-for-writ-of-certiorari principal-debtor-and-guarantor radacon-liberia-limited restructuring-of-loan set-off simeon-freeman supreme-court-of-liberia unauthorized-debit writ-practice2020-1 banking-law civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases property-law-cases supreme-court
Ecobank v Kakata Holding Company et al LRSC 2 (2013), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ecobank-v-kakata-holding-company-et-al-lrsc-2-20132013-opinions appellate-review bailor-bailee-relationship bank-charges-and-fees banking-law breach-of-contract commercial-law contract-law damages ecobank-liberia-limited escrow-account fiduciary-obligations-of-banks kakata-holding-company letter-of-credit margibi-county ministry-of-education-contract modification-of-judgment mutual-benefits-assurance-company performance-bond setoff special-deposit summary-judgment supreme-court-of-liberia tripartite-memorandum-of-understanding2013-1 banking-law civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases supreme-court
Farhat v. The Management of the Liberia Trading and Development Bank (TRADEVCO) (2016), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , farhat-v-the-management-of-the-liberia-trading-and-development-bank-tradevco-20162016-opinions appellate-review bank-records banking-law best-evidence-rule burden-of-proof central-bank-of-liberia civil-law civil-war commercial-law debt debt-court documentary-evidence financial-institutions judicial-notice liquidation montserrado-county savings-account substantial-justice supreme-court-of-liberia uncertified-copies2016-1 banking-law commercial-law-cases evidence-law supreme-court
Firestone Liberia Inc. v MARDCO LRSC 16 (2016), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , firestone-liberia-inc-v-mardco-lrsc-16-20162016-opinions accounting-proceedings agency-relationship ambiguity-in-contract award-of-punitive-damages breach-of-contract burden-of-proof business-losses civil-law commercial-law construction-against-drafter contract-law contractual-interpretation corporate-liability corporate-officer-misconduct corporate-transactions damages-for-breach-of-contract deterrence-principle estoppel failure-to-prove-general-damages fiduciary-breach financial-mismanagement firestone-v-kollie general-damages good-faith-and-fair-dealing improper-payment insufficiency-of-evidence intrusco-corp-v-ossely konn lonestar-v-wright memorandum-of-understanding modification-of-damages notice-and-noncompliance payment-dispute pleading-and-proof-of-special-damages preponderance-of-evidence proof-of-damages punitive-damages separate-causes-of-action special-damages supreme-court-of-liberia third-party-liability unjust-enrichment willful-breach2016-1 commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases corporate-law-case evidence-law supreme-court
Griffiths v RL LRSC 77; 22 LLR 288 (1973), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , griffiths-v-rl-lrsc-77-22-llr-288-19731973-opinions abuse-of-criminal-process appellate-review bad-checks bank-checks business-transactions circumstantial-evidence commercial-law construction-of-statutes criminal-law criminal-procedure debt-action debt-collection-abuse dishonored-checks double-jeopardy drawer-of-check evidence felonious-intent fine first-judicial-circuit fraud grand-larceny indictment indictment-sufficiency insufficient-funds intent-to-defraud international-trust-company-of-liberia larceny liberia-trading-corporation lis-pendens montserrado-county notice-of-dishonor private-prosecutor remand replevin restitution retrial self-incrimination statutory-interpretation subpoena-duces-tecum supreme-court-of-liberia ten-day-notice worthless-checks written-notice1973-1 banking-law commercial-law-cases criminal-law-cases supreme-court
Guaranty Trust (GT) Bank v. Sirleaf (2023), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , guaranty-trust-gt-bank-v-sirleaf-20232023-opinions adverse-inference appellate-review banking-law best-evidence-rule bojelene-guest-house-inc breach-of-deposit-contract burden-of-proof charles-e-sirleaf commercial-court-of-liberia commercial-law contract-law contributory-negligence costs credibility-of-witnesses deposit-contract evidentiary-standards excessive-damages expert-witness failure-to-testify forensic-examination forged-signature fraudulent-withdrawals general-damages gt-bank-liberia-limited guaranty-trust-bank-liberia-limited handwriting-analysis liberia-national-police mandate mitigation-of-damages monrovia montserrado-county preponderance-of-evidence punitive-damages qualification-of-expert questioned-documents remand reversal-on-appeal sms-alert-deactivation special-damages subpoenaed-witnesses supreme-court-of-liberia2023-1 banking-law civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases evidence-law private-wrongs-law-cases supreme-court
Gulley et al. v The intestate Estate of the late Ethel Kaba Gayflorzee LRSC 1 (2016), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , gulley-et-al-v-the-intestate-estate-of-the-late-ethel-kaba-gayflorzee-lrsc-1-2016chambers-justice ejectment foreclosure intestate-estate joint-tenancy judicial-sale liberia-supreme-court mortgage-law nhsb prohibition real-property service-by-publication sheriffs-deed survivorship2016-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases property-law-cases supreme-court
Intestate Estate of Musa kamara v. Her Honor Eva Mappy Morgan (2023), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , intestate-estate-of-musa-kamara-v-her-honor-eva-mappy-morgan-20232023-opinions adverse-claim appellate-procedure banking-law bill-of-information cognizability commercial-court-of-liberia commercial-law creditors-remedies debt-recovery dismissal-of-appeal due-process enforcement-of-judgment enforcement-proceedings estate-administration execution-of-mandate failure-to-perfect-appeal fair-hearing finality-of-judgment foreclosure-sale holder-v-intestate-estate-of-sarah-king-howard improper-execution international-bank-liberia-limited intestate-estate-of-musa-m-kamara judicial-auction judicial-review jurisdiction kpoto-v-kpoto mandate-of-the-supreme-court monrovia montserrado-county mortgage-foreclosure motion-to-dismiss-appeal procedural-irregularities property-rights rule-iv-part-12-supreme-court-rules sheriff-sale special-proceedings sr supreme-court-of-liberia2023-1 banking-law civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases inheritance-law-cases judiciary-law property-law-cases supreme-court
Intrusco Corp. v Firetex Inc. LRSC 10; 32 LLR 11 (1984), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , intrusco-corp-v-firetex-inc-lrsc-10-32-llr-11-19841984-opinions accord-and-satisfaction appearance-equals-service bill-of-exceptions civil-law contract-for-services costs debt-action evidence inconsistency-in-pleadings investigative-services judgment-affirmed montserrado-county motion-to-dismiss personal-jurisdiction release-and-estoppel service-of-summons successful-counsels-fee supreme-court-of-liberia venue verification-of-pleadings1984-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases evidence-law supreme-court
J. Annan Automobile Export and Effestrasse v. Yourne Trading Company, Inc. et al. (2025), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , inc-et-al-2025 j-annan-automobile-export-and-effestrasse-v-yourne-trading-company2025-opinions appeal-dismissal article-iv3 civil-procedure commercial-code commercial-court enforcement-of-judgment escrow-account foreclosure-auction jurisdiction liberia-supreme-court monetary-judgment mortgage-foreclosure motion-to-dismiss2025-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases property-law-cases supreme-court
Jun v Kamand (2024), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , jun-v-kamand-2024 the-management-of-the-national-port-authority-v-sekou-h-dukuly-20242024-opinions action-of-debt-by-attachment appeal-bond appeal-dismissibility appellate-review bill-of-exceptions civil-law clerks-certificate debt-court enforcement-of-judgment jurisdictional-requirements montserrado-county motion-to-dismiss-appeal notice-of-completion-of-appeal partial-payment procedural-default stipulation-negotiation supreme-court-of-liberia2024-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases supreme-court
Kamand v Jun (2023), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , kamand-v-jun-20232023 2023-opinions abuse-of-process action-of-debt-by-attachment appeal april-19 attorney-discipline certiorari civil-law code-of-moral-and-professional-ethics commercial-code commercial-court concurrent-jurisdiction continuance debt-court default-judgment-application dilatory-tactics disputed-signature doctrine-of-recency fines fraud-allegation judgment-during-trial jurisdictional-threshold loan-agreement mandamus-to-resume-jurisdiction mixed-issues-of-law-and-fact monrovia montserrado-county motion-to-refuse-jurisdiction new-judiciary-law petition-for-writ-of-certiorari plain-meaning-rule promissory-note sanctions statutory-interpretation subject-matter-jurisdiction supreme-court-of-liberia2023-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases ethics supreme-court
Kamara v International Bank Liberia Limited (2025), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , kamara-v-international-bank-liberia-limited-2025appellate-review civil-law-court concurrent-jurisdiction foreclosure judicial-error judicial-review mandate-compliance mortgage mortgage-law motion-to-rescind procedural-fairness rescission-of-ruling supreme-court-of-liberia term-time unjust-enrichment writ-of-certiorari2025-1 banking-law civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases property-law-cases supreme-court
Knowlden v The Heirs of Cooper (2025), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , knowlden-v-the-heirs-of-cooper-20252025-opinions adverse-possession affirmation-of-judgment appellate-review bona-fide-purchaser buyer-beware carey-street caveat civil-law-court ejectment eviction executors-deed honorable-purchase illegal-occupancy interpretation-of-wills jury-verdict land-dispute lease life-estate mandate monrovia montserrado-county mortgage-claim motion-for-new-trial probate property-ownership randall-street real-property remainder-interest remaindermen rent-collection statute-of-limitations supreme-court-of-liberia tenants testamentary-intent title-deed warranty-deed weight-of-evidence will-and-testament writ-of-possession wrongful-withholding2025-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases evidence-law inheritance-law-cases property-law-cases supreme-court
Kwaplah International (Liberia) v. The Management of Ecobank (Liberia) Limited (2022), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , kwaplah-international-liberia-v-the-management-of-ecobank-liberia-limited-20222022-opinions abenego-dahn abuse-of-discretion account-statement agency alleged-fraud apparent-authority appeal-denied authority-of-corporate-officer banking-law banking-practices-and-procedures bench-trial best-evidence-rule burden-of-proof central-bank-of-liberia check-clearing civil-law civil-law-court clearing-house clearing-period commensurate-damages commercial-banking competency-of-expert corporate-account corporate-personhood costs-taxed cpl-26-2 criminal-conviction-and-restitution damages-for-wrong dismissal-without-prejudice documentary-evidence dropping-of-parties due-diligence ecobank-liberia-limited expert-witness forged-board-resolution general-damages harrison-luo judgment-during-trial judicial-discretion kwaplah-international-liberia mandate misapplication-of-entrusted-property montserrado-county motion-for-summary-judgment negligence opening-of-corporate-account over-the-counter-encashment parent-subsidiary-relationship preponderance-of-the-evidence proof-of-affiliation proof-of-injury regulatory-compliance restitution separate-legal-entity sixth-judicial-circuit special-damages speculative-damages standard-of-care standard-operating-procedures supreme-court-of-liberia theft-of-property tort unjust-enrichment2022-1 banking-law civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases corporate-law-case evidence-law private-wrongs-law-cases supreme-court
Liberian Agricultural Company (LAC) v Associated Development Company (ADC) LRSC 1 (2012), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , lac-v-adc-lrsc-1-2012 liberian-agricultural-company-lac-v-associated-development-company-adc-lrsc-1-20122012-opinions action-of-debt admission-against-interest affirmation-of-judgment agency-law appeal-bond appellate-review associated-development-company-adc best-evidence-rule buchanan-port burden-of-proof catholic-relief-services-crs civil-law commercial-transactions debt-court-of-montserrado-county documentary-evidence enforcement-of-judgment-pending-appeal ina-decree-no-12 jurisdiction liberian-agricultural-company-lac offset-and-set-off reimbursement-of-expenses renovation-contract statute-of-frauds subpoena-duces-tecum supreme-court-of-liberia telegraphic-transfer warehouse-lease2012-1 agency-law civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases evidence-law property-law-cases supreme-court
Liminco v. Judge Paye et al. LRSC1 (2017), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , liminco-v-judge-paye-et-al-lrsc1-20172017-opinions abuse-of-discretion appellate-review arbitration-clause assignment-of-rights breach-of-contract civil-procedure conflict-of-interest conflict-of-jurisdiction constitutional-law contract-law corporate-law default-judgment due-process ecowas-court enforcement-of-judgment estoppel fraud iron-ore-agreement judicial-misconduct jurisdiction legal-ethics mining-law ministry-of-justice montserrado-county natural-resources notice-of-assignment public-auction receivership reversal service-of-process sixth-judicial-circuit special-jury supreme-court-of-liberia verification-of-pleadings writ-of-prohibition2017-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases constitutional-law-cases ethics supreme-court
Lloyd’s Insurance v Trading Co. LRSC 5; 24 LLR 70 (1975), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , lloyds-insurance-v-trading-co-lrsc-5-24-llr-70-19751975-opinions appellate-review burden-of-proof civil-law commercial-law contract-law damages indemnity insurable-interest insurance-law interpretation-of-insurance-contract liability marine-insurance subrogation supreme-court-of-liberia1975-1 commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases evidence-law maritime-law supreme-court
Manhattan Trading Corp. V. World Bank LRSC 26 (2016), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , manhattan-trading-corp-v-world-bank-lrsc-26-2016appeal-bond appeal-bond-requirement-cpl-51-8 declaratory-judgment exception-to-surety-cpl-63-5 fda-v-fda-workers-union indemnification insurance-company-surety-ica intercon-security-systems-v-philips jurisdiction-divestiture-trial-court justice-wolokollie kerpai-v-kpene lease-dispute liberia-civil-procedure manhattan-trading-corporation-v-world-bank motion-to-dismiss-appeal notice-of-completion-of-appeal nunc-pro-tunc procedural-waiver regulatory-certification-of-surety sufficiency-of-surety summary-judgment supreme-court-of-liberia thompson-v-george unpaid-rent waiver-and-laches2016-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases property-law-cases supreme-court
Marpleh et al v RL LRSC 33; 19 LLR 335 (1969), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , marpleh-et-al-v-rl-lrsc-33-19-llr-335-19691969-opinions accessory-after-the-fact aiding-felon appellate-review bearer-instrument best-evidence-rule burden-of-proof bureau-of-general-accounting-and-audits corpus-delicti court-administrator criminal-law criminal-participation cross-examination directed-verdict escape-from-punishment evidence evidentiary-error false-payroll-entries fictitious-employees fictitious-payee first-judicial-circuit forged-endorsements fraudulent-payroll government-checks grand-larceny harmless-error judicial-finance-fraud judiciary-payroll jury-trial jury-verdict larceny merchant-testimony montserrado-county negotiable-instruments nimba-county-debt-court payroll-clerk-testimony payroll-fraud plea-of-not-guilty pre-audit-irregularities principal-and-accessory-distinction prosecution-witnesses reasonable-doubt supreme-court-of-liberia treasury-department variance variance-between-indictment-and-proof voucher-fraud1969-1 commercial-law-cases criminal-law-cases evidence-law supreme-court
Meridian Bank BIAO et al.v. Cllr. Benedict F. Sannoh (2025), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , selma-v-gorpudolo-2025-bill-of-information2025-opinions attorney-retainer bank-seizure central-bank-of-liberia contract-termination debt-action financial-institutions-act jurisdiction receivership rule-5-debt-court statutory-time-limit supreme-court-of-liberia void-ab-initio2025-1 banking-law civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases supreme-court
Misoschewsk et al v. Afriland First Bank (2025), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , misoschewsk-et-al-v-afriland-first-bank-20252025-opinions afriland-first-bank associations-law banking-law capacity-to-sue certiorari civil-procedure corporate-law corporate-personality deposit-contract jurisdiction liberia-supreme-court standing2025-1 banking-law civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases supreme-court
Modern Development & Management Corporation (MDMC) v Government of the Republic of Liberia (2025) (Bill of Information), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , modern-development-management-corporation-mdmc-v-government-of-the-republic-of-liberia-2025-bill-of-information2025-opinions bill-of-information chambers-justice compliance-with-mandate concession-agreement contempt-of-court drivers-license enforcement-of-court-orders enforcement-pending-appeal judicial-notice liberia-traffic-management-incorporated ministry-of-justice ministry-of-transport modern-development-management-corporation montserrado-county privy-parties prohibition-appeal public-private-partnership stay-order supreme-court-of-liberia vehicle-registration writ-of-prohibition2025-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases supreme-court
Morgan v Barclay et al. LRSC 22; 42 LLR 259 (2004), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , morgan-v-barclay-et-al-lrsc-22-42-llr-259-20042004-opinions civil-law-court conveyance ejectment executors-duty jury-verdict leasehold legal-capacity-to-sue mixed-issues-of-law-and-fact montserrado-county preponderance-of-evidence probate-court standing-to-sue supreme-court-of-liberia testate-estate unjust-enrichment void-transaction2004-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases evidence-law property-law-cases supreme-court
Mutual Benefit Assurance Company (MBAC) v. Bea Mountains Mining Corporation (BMMC) (2023), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , mutual-benefit-assurance-company-mbac-v-bea-mountains-mining-corporation-bmmc-20232023-opinions abuse-of-process action-of-debt affirmation affirmation-of-lower-court appeal-process appellate-review arbitration-award arbitration-proceedings article-iv bea-mountain-mining-corporation bill-of-costs bill-of-exceptions breach-of-contract chambers-justice-ruling civil-procedure commercial-code-section-7-54 commercial-court commercial-court-act commercial-law completion-of-appeal construction-contract contractual-liability corrective-remedy debt-action denial-of-writ enforcement-of-arbitral-award enforcement-of-award-as-judgment enforcement-of-judgment escrow-account-deposit escrow-requirement foreign-arbitral-award guarantee-bond indemnity-obligation interlocutory-vs-final-judgment international-construction-engineering-ice jurisdiction jurisdictional-challenge london-arbitration mandate monrovia montserrado-county mutual-benefit-assurance-company perfection-of-appeal performance-bond petition-for-prohibition pretrial-conference preventive-remedy privity-of-contract prohibition-not-substitute-for-appeal remedial-writs statutory-compliance stay-of-enforcement summary-judgment supreme-court-of-liberia trial-court-error-allegations writ-of-prohibition2023-1 arbitration civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases supreme-court
Mutual Benefit Assurance Company v Bea Mountains Corporation (2025), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , mutual-benefit-assurance-company-vs-bea-mountains-corporation-20252025-opinions action-of-debt advance-payment-guarantee appeal appeal-process arbitration-award arbitration-clause aureus-mining-inc bea-mountain-mining-corporation bill-of-information chambers-justice-ruling commercial-court commercial-court-act contempt-of-court escrow-account indemnity-bond international-construction-engineering-liberia-inc irregularity-in-execution jurisdiction mandate-enforcement montserrado-county mutual-benefit-assurance-company performance-bond prohibition supreme-court-of-liberia2025-1 arbitration civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases supreme-court
Natural Resources Development Corporation (NRDC) v The Intestate of Macdonald A. Wento (2026), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , natural-resources-development-corporation-nrdc-v-the-intestate-of-macdonald-a-wento-20262026-opinions actual-controversy agency-relationship alternative-dispute-resolution appellate-review arbitration-agreement arbitration-clause arbitration-vs-court-jurisdiction authority-of-counsel board-resolution civil-law civil-law-court civil-procedure-law-chapter-43 civil-procedure-law-section-164-1 civil-procedure-law-section-43-5 commercial-law contractual-arbitration corporate-concession-dispute corporate-governance corporate-law declaratory-judgment declaratory-relief-scope dismissal-of-action equity-interest estate-administration forest-concession injunction-relief interested-party-requirement intestate-estate jurisdiction law-firm-authority legal-capacity liberia-corporate-dispute logging-rights mandate-to-lower-court montserrado-county motion-to-dismiss ownership-dispute petition-for-declaratory-judgment pleadings preliminary-injunction proof-of-ownership reversal-on-appeal share-certificates share-transfer shareholders-rights shareholding-dispute sixth-judicial-circuit standing-to-sue subject-matter-jurisdiction supreme-court-of-liberia temporary-restraining-order2026-1 arbitration civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases corporate-law-case supreme-court
Novomatic Gaming Industry GmbH v. Palm Spring Gaming Company (2025), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , novomatic-gaming-industry-gmbh-v-palm-spring-gaming-company-20252025-opinions action-to-recover-chattel appellate-review arbitration-clause arbitration-enforceability article-25-constitution-of-liberia breach-of-contract chicri-brothers-v-isuzu-motors civil-law-court contractual-waiver corporate-authorization enforcement-of-contract foreign-governing-law gaming-machines international-chamber-of-commerce-arbitration international-commercial-arbitration judgment-affirmed jurisdiction lease-agreement montserrado-county motion-to-dismiss obligation-of-contracts power-of-attorney standing-to-sue supreme-court-of-liberia vienna-austria2025-1 arbitration civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases supreme-court
Patrick Vision Inc. v Arcelor Mittal Liberia (2025), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , patrick-vision-inc-v-arcelor-mittal-liberia-20252025-opinions appeal appellate-review arbitration arbitration-clause civil-law contracts damages-for-wrong destruction-of-property international-chamber-of-commerce-arbitration jurisdiction montserrado-county motion-to-dismiss reversal-and-remand sanctity-of-contracts supreme-court-of-liberia termination-of-contract tortious-conduct wrongful-seizure-of-property2025-1 arbitration civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases private-wrongs-law-cases supreme-court
Pioneer Construction Company v Her Honor Morgan et al. LRSC 41 (2015), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , pioneer-construction-company-v-her-honor-morgan-et-al-lrsc-41-20152015-opinions action-of-debt appeal-bond appellate-procedure article-20b banking-law civil-procedure commercial-court-of-liberia commercial-law condition-precedent-to-appeal constitutional-law constitutionality-of-statute enforcement-of-judgment escrow-account international-bank-liberia-limited judicial-discretion judicial-review judiciary-law legislative-authority loan-agreement mandamus-denied monrovia montserrado-county mortgage-deed payment-of-judgment personal-guarantee petition-for-writ-of-mandamus pioneer-construction-company prerogative-writs promissory-note restructured-loan right-of-appeal separation-of-powers statutory-interpretation stay-of-execution summary-judgment supreme-court-of-liberia title-172015-1 banking-law civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases constitutional-law-cases supreme-court
Prince D. Jegbadai et al. v The Liberian Bank for Development & Investment (2025), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , prince-d-jegbadai-et-al-vs-the-liberian-bank-for-development-investment-20252025-opinions civil-procedure concurrent-jurisdiction foreclosure-of-mortgage letters-of-administration motion-for-relief-from-judgment probate-law procedural-law reasonable-time standing supreme-court-of-liberia2025-1 banking-law civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases property-law-cases supreme-court
RL v Bernice Trading Center LRSC 54 (2014), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , rl-v-bernice-trading-center-lrsc-54-20142014-opinions administrative-law administrative-procedure-act administrative-remedies bernice-trading-center commercial-regulation due-process exhaustion-of-remedies import-regulation judicial-review ministry-of-commerce-and-industry obscenity-regulation prohibition regulation-of-commerce supreme-court-of-liberia ultra-vires-administrative-action writ-of-prohibition2014-1 administrative-law commercial-law-cases supreme-court
Srimex Oil and Gas Company v His Honor George W. Smith et al (2025), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , srimex-oil-and-gas-company-v-his-honor-george-w-smith-et-al-20252025-opinions 50-50-revenue-sharing access-to-evidence administrative-costs appellate-jurisdiction auditing-and-accounting bill-of-information capital-expenditure civil-law-court civil-procedure comprehensive-financial-audit construction-costs cost-allocation court-ordered-audit credit-suisse-records deviation-from-mandate dilatory-tactics due-process improper-execution-of-mandate instructions-to-trial-court insurance international-commercial-dispute legal-fees mandate-enforcement mandate-to-resume-jurisdiction monrovia montserrado-county notice-and-opportunity-to-be-heard oil-and-gas operational-expenses outstanding-balance-liability petroleum-terminal reimbursement-of-investment remand rent revenue-accounting salaries-and-wages scope-of-mandate sixth-judicial-circuit storage-and-sale-of-petroleum-products supervisory-jurisdiction supreme-court-of-liberia switzerland third-party-confirmations transparency-and-fairness underlying-source-documents waiver-and-laches2025-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases supreme-court
Stoner Liberia Inc. vs. Ecobank Liberia Limited (2023), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , stoner-liberia-inc-vs-ecobank-liberia-limited-20232023-opinions action-of-debt admission-of-indebtedness article-iii4 banking-law civil-procedure collateral-source-of-repayment commercial-court-of-liberia-act commercial-law costs-taxed damages-award debt-by-attachment ecobank-liberia-limited eva-mappy-morgan extraordinary-writ guaranty-third-party-responsibility interlocutory-ruling joinder-of-parties judicial-notice jurisdiction loan-facility mandate monrovia montserrado-county moot-by-operation-of-law mootness motion-to-join-indispensable-party no-genuine-issue-of-material-fact prior-supreme-court-judgment proceeding-by-wrong-rules prohibition-as-remedy prohibition-not-substitute-for-appeal prompt-determination-of-commercial-disputes remand-to-court-below res-judicata-principles review-of-interlocutory-ruling single-judge-ruling stoner-liberia-inc sua-sponte-dismissal summary-judgment supreme-court-of-liberia three-judge-panel total-liberia-inc window-for-review writ-of-prohibition2023-1 banking-law civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases supreme-court
Tarpeh v RL LRSC 5; 34 LLR 334 (1987), , , , , , , , , , , , , tarpeh-v-rl-lrsc-5-34-llr-334-19871987-opinions action-of-debt-by-attachment compromise-and-settlement conversion-of-funds creditor-debtor-relationship criminal-law debt embezzlement private-prosecutrix promissory-note supreme-court-of-liberia voluntary-transfer-of-title1987-1 commercial-law-cases criminal-law-cases supreme-court
The Central Bank of the Republic of Liberia (CBL) v Doe LRSC 2 (2015), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , cbl-v-doe-lrsc-2-2015 the-central-bank-of-the-republic-of-liberia-cbl-v-doe-lrsc-2-20152015-opinions abandoned-property action-of-debt appeal-bond-requirement appellate-review banking-law best-evidence-rule burden-of-proof central-bank-of-liberia citibank-liberia civil-law commercial-court commercial-law constitutional-challenge costs-disallowed deposit-contract depositor-rights dormant-account escrow-pending-appeal fiduciary-duty fifteen-year-rule financial-institutions-law general-agent judicial-notice liquidation-plan mandate meridian-bank-liberia-limited montserrado-county mootness national-bank-of-liberia passbook-evidence paying-agent-agreement preponderance-of-evidence proof-of-payment reversal-of-judgment savings-account statute-of-limitations statutory-presumption-of-abandonment supreme-court-of-liberia trust-account unclaimed-deposits voluntary-liquidation winding-up2015-1 agency-law civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases evidence-law supreme-court
The ECOWAS Bank for Investment and Development (EBID) Vs United Commodities Inc. (2020), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , the-ecowas-bank-for-investment-and-development-ebid-vs-united-commodities-inc-20202020-opinions appellate-review banking-and-finance-law breach-of-contract civil-law collateral-management commercial-law contractual-interpretation costs damaged-goods default-on-loan ebola-outbreak ecowas-bank-for-investment-and-development-ebid escrow-account field-warehousing-agreement force-majeure foreclosure-rights impossibility-of-performance insurance-obligation international-finance liberia-bank-for-development-and-investment-lbdi loan-agreement mandate montserrado-county mortgage-security personal-guarantees petition-for-declaratory-judgment reversal-of-trial-court-judgment risk-of-loss supreme-court-of-liberia unconditional-liability united-commodities-inc unjust-enrichment2020-1 banking-law civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases health-law insurance-law supreme-court
The Intestate Estate of John N. Lewis v Kumba Bendu and Sons (2024), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , the-intestate-estate-of-john-n-lewis-vs-kumba-bendu-and-sons-20242024 action-of-debt appeal appellate-review bill-of-information civil-law civil-law-court civil-procedure commercial-tenancy competing-judgments debt-court due-process ejectment enforcement-of-judgment escrow-account interlocutory-ruling judicial-review lease-agreement montserrado-county party-of-interest petition-for-certiorari prejudicial-error property-ownership-dispute rental-arrears standing-and-capacity sub-lease supreme-court-of-liberia title-to-real-property writ-of-certiorari2024-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases property-law-cases supreme-court
The Liberian Bank for Development & Investment v BMC Workers of Bong Mining Company (2025), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , the-liberian-bank-for-development-investment-v-bmc-workers-of-bong-mining-company-20252010-settlement appeal attorney-ethics banker-depositor-relationship bong-mining-company-bmc civil-law-court-montserrado client-consent damages-for-wrong judgment-satisfaction-10-year judicial-notice lbdi liberia-case-law-2025 memorandum-of-understanding-mou ministry-of-finance-circular-1-1983 redundancy-payments settlement-release statute-of-limitations supreme-court-of-liberia unmeritorious-suit writ-of-prohibition2025-1 banking-law civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases ethics supreme-court
The Management of Ecobank Liberia Limited v. Embassy Suite Corporation (2023), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , the-management-of-ecobank-liberia-limited-v-embassy-suite-corporation-20232023-opinion absence-of-board-resolution action-of-damages-for-wrong appeal collateral-vip-premises-name-change commercial-court-debt-by-attachment-and-garnishment damages-without-proof-of-injury ecobank-liberia-limited-v-embassy-suite-corporation joint-and-several-loan-obligation lack-of-corporate-existence-at-time-of-wrong no-transfer-of-assets-or-liabilities ruling-reversed sole-proprietorship-vs-corporation standing-to-sue successor-liability-not-proven supreme-court-of-liberia tort-law ultra-vires-corporate-act verdict-against-weight-of-evidence2023-1 banking-law commercial-law-cases corporate-law-case evidence-law private-wrongs-law-cases supreme-court
Urban Marketing, Inc. v. John Hilary Tubman (2024), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , inc-v-john-hilary-tubman-2024 urban-marketing2024-opinions arbitration arbitration-award-confirmation article-25-constitution cancellation-of-agreement chapter-64-civil-procedure-law civil-law-court contract-breach due-process john-hilary-tubman joint-venture montserrado-county petition-to-compel-arbitration real-property sanctity-of-contract sinkor supreme-court-of-liberia urban-marketing-inc2024-1 arbitration commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases supreme-court
Vrex Remodeling Inc. v. LPRC (2016), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , vrex-remodeling-inc-v-lprc-20162016-opinion administrative-procedure-act agency-error arbitrary-and-capricious carp conditional-award docket-advancement enforcement-petition judicial-review liberia-supreme-court lprc lutech-engineering ministry-of-justice ppcc prequalification procurement-law public-safety record-evidence technical-requirements vrex-remodeling2016-1 administrative-law anti-corruption civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases procurement-law supreme-court
Woiwor v Pol (2025), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , woiwor-v-pol-20252025-opinions action-of-debt appellate-review breach-of-contract civil-law commercial-dispute conditional-contract contractual-interpretation debt-by-attachment debt-court directed-verdict disputed-facts documentary-evidence financial-investment-agreement interest-and-commission loan-agreement mandate monrovia montserrado-county motion-for-judgment-during-trial post-dated-cheque preponderance-of-evidence prima-facie-case remand-for-full-trial reversal-of-trial-court sufficiency-of-evidence supreme-court-of-liberia unjust-enrichment2025-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases supreme-court
Youth for Development & Productivity (YODAP) v The Government of the Republic of Liberia (2026), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , youth-for-development-productivity-yodap-v-the-government-of-the-republic-of-liberia-20262026-opinions absence-of-contract acknowledgment-of-debt action-of-debt affirmance-of-lower-court appellate-review best-evidence-rule bilateral-agreement burden-of-proof civil-law commercial-court commercial-law contract-law corporate-capacity corporate-entity debt-recovery defective-writ-of-summons denial-of-claim dismissal-of-action documentary-evidence domestic-debt-validation evidentiary-insufficiency failure-of-proof failure-to-prove-claim financing-arrangement fraud-allegation government-liability government-of-liberia jurisdiction lack-of-consideration legal-personality limitation-period loan-agreement mandate ministry-of-finance-and-development-planning montserrado-county non-governmental-organization performance-of-contract pre-financing-claim privity-of-contract proof-of-performance public-finance rebuttal-evidence remand republic-of-china-taiwan self-serving-evidence service-of-process sovereign-obligations standing statute-of-frauds statute-of-limitations sufficiency-of-evidence supreme-court-of-liberia third-party-beneficiary unenforceable-contract witness-credibility written-contract-requirement2026-1 civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases evidence-law international-law-case supreme-court
Yuones et al vs. His Honor James E. Jones et al (2024), , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , joseph-yuones-and-wacco-vs-his-honor-james-e-jones-judge-debt-and-houssini-2024 yuones-et-al-vs-his-honor-james-e-jones-et-al-20242024-opinions action-of-debt admissions alter-ego-doctrine assignment attachment bill-of-costs blacks-law-dictionary civil-procedure commercial-code consideration contract corporate-officer corporate-veil debt-court default-judgment domestic-corporation enforcement-of-judgment extraordinary-writs imperfect-judgment jurisdiction managing-agent mandate ministry-of-foreign-affairs-as-statutory-agent negotiable-instrument personal-service prohibition-proceeding registered-agent resummons service-by-publication service-of-process sole-shareholder-corporation supreme-court-of-liberia wacco writ-of-prohibition2024-1 agency-law civil-procedure-law-cases commercial-law-cases contract-law-cases corporate-law-case supreme-court